
Robert M. Goodman Ph.D.
MADISON, Wisconsin -- Obesity and hunger coexist in the
United States. Farmers in China rebel against low prices and high
taxes. India raises excess grain but leaves its people malnourished
in protein. Consumers rebel against genetically modified foods in
Europe, where pesticide and fertilizer use is ubiquitous and
uncontroversial.
These are a few of the visible issues that swirl around world
agriculture today. More profound but less visible an issue is world
food security. World population will grow in the next 30 years to 9
billion. All of this growth will occur in the less developed countries,
where more than 2 billion people, mostly children, already suffer
from grinding poverty, malnutrition, hunger and sometimes famine.
In these countries the population will rise from 4 to 7 billion in a
single generation. No one has a clue about how these people will
be fed.
Since 1960, as world population doubled, agriculture has
performed a small miracle. For the first time in human history,
increasing food production came not primarily from using more
land for crops but from advances in science. Any future increases
in production will likewise depend upon wise investments in
science.
Philanthropic dollars are trickling in - from the Gates, Rockefeller,
Kellogg and Mc-Knight foundations, to name a few that work to
improve nutrition by funding agricultural research. But it isn't
enough.
The Green Revolution, which foundations and governments
supported in the 1960s, made agriculture vastly more productive
by increasing yields. But today's challenge goes beyond increased
yields.
As agriculture was industrialized, first by machines and then by
chemistry (pesticides and fertilizers), the environment suffered. The
19th century's westward expansion in North America was in part
driven by impoverishment of soils in the East. Intensive tillage
made possible by mechanization helped create the Dust Bowl of
the 1930s. Fertilizer runoff today pollutes rivers, lakes and
groundwater. Pesticides damage beneficial organisms and force
the evolution of resistant pests, making things worse in the long
term while making them seem better in the near. Yet now we are
forced to build future increases in food production on this shaky
foundation.
What shall we do in the developing countries of Africa, Asia and
Latin America, where the pressure of population, the
underinvestment in infrastructure, the degradation of the
environment and the constraints of natural resources conspire to
make hunger acute in the coming decades? Should we be
promoting, as many are, adoption by developing countries of
industrialized methods that are failing at home?
I say "no." We should apply programs that empower the people of
developing countries to better feed themselves. Instead of food aid
in crises, we should invest for the long haul in research that equips
them to make decisions about agriculture that fit within their
societies, environments and economies. It also will help them be
intelligent shoppers for appropriate technologies that enable them
to make progress.
Today's situation is much more difficult than the problem the
developed world solved in the Green Revolution. Population has
doubled and will double again. Technologies used in agriculture,
including genetics and genomics, are controversial. Today we
understand the environmental damage caused by some of the very
methods that were seen as solutions back then. And today we in
the developed world lack the political will to invest in agricultural
development for developing countries.
For all of these reasons, we must look to philanthropic foundations
and others of vision and means to step up to this challenge. With
their resources and broad commitment to a better quality of life
throughout the world, they can provide the leadership and money
that will again draw public interest - and, in time, governmental
commitment - to investment in agricultural advances in the poorer
nations.
These nations need strong public institutions for agriculture and
significant additional investments in research. And they need
access to the best and most appropriate technologies, from
modern genetics to organic methods, to serve the needs of farmers
and local entrepreneurs who will play the critical roles. History
shows the political consequences of hunger, disease and starvation
in the human family. The scale of disaster that could result from
agriculture's failure in the less developed countries would far
exceed anything we have experienced.
The writer is professor of plant pathology, molecular biology
and environmental studies at the University of Wisconsin in
Madison and chair of the oversight committee of the
McKnight Foundation's Collaborative Crop Research
Program. He contributed this comment to the International
Herald Tribune.
* NOTICE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed for research and educational purposes only. **
|
|
|
Last Updated on 4/2/01 Email: information@biotech-info.net |
|