
Philippine Daily Inquirer
Manila Archbishop Jaime Cardinal Sin has urged the use of safe
alternatives to genetically modified organism (GMO) in the country in a
pastoral statement issued amid claims of agrochemical firms the
technology has church backing.
"Genetic engineering is acceptable only if all risks are minimized," he
said. "Otherwise, one may easily succumb to temptations of productivity
and profit at the expense of the people and the environment."
The archbishop's statement echoed Vatican's latest position on this
biotechnological issue that sharply divides scientists and researchers
all over the world.
Speaking before an estimated 50,000 farmers from Italy and elsewhere at
a special outdoor mass for farmers, Pope John Paul II said on November
last year that using GMO to increase farm production was contrary to
God's will.
"As long as foreseeable dangers are not fully identified, studied and
avoided, safe alternative procedures should be used," said the
influential archbishop of Manila. "(I)f none, testing and development of
the technology should be delayed altogether."
In a bid to win over support of the predominantly Catholic populace of
the country, the proponents of GMO use in public fora and promotional
materials the old Vatican statement endorsing genetic engineering to
improve living conditions of farmers.
Sin said "certain experiments and marketing strategies may have
detrimental effects on different areas of human existence, such as
health and safety, environment and biodiversity, culture, consumers
rights and proper distribution of food and earnings."
There is still no consensus among scientists worldwide over the issue of
the technology's safety, and failures in many GMO farms cast doubts on
the efficacy of it.
Current field testing in the country will not respond to safety queries
as they are confined on proving the effectiveness of the technology.
Farmers decry meanwhile that modern biotechnology will simply tighten
the grip of agrochemical firms on agriculture with GMO seeds patented to
global food and chemical giants.
"While technology merely asks, 'can it be done?, ethics on the other
hand brings us one step farther and asks, 'if it can be done, should it
be done?'" said Sin in the statement obtained by the Inquirer.
Through genetic engineering, natural and conventional processes of
improving traits of living organisms are now being abandoned for the
still infantile technology.
By manipulating genetic makeup in an organism, characteristics could be
altered or modified in a process that transcends species boundaries.
As such, genetic engineering represents awesome, God-like powers to
create, change and direct evolution of all life, from microorganisms to
human beings.
Transnational firms Monsanto and Pioneer have been conducting open-field
testing of genetically engineered Bt corn in Mindanao while experiments
on transgenic rice varieties by the International Rice Research
Institute are awaiting approval of the Philippine biosafety regulatory
agency.
The Macapagal-Arroyo administration vowed to hold broad consultations on
the issue amid calls of civil society groups for a moratorium of GMO
open-field experiments in the country.
** NOTICE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed for research and educational purposes only. ** |
|
|
Last Updated on 7/17/01 Email: information@biotech-info.net |
|