
Jennifer L. Rich New York Times November 16, 2001
SÃO PAULO, Brazil, Nov. 15 — The Brazilian government, which has challenged
the giant drug companies' patent defenses perhaps more aggressively than any
other country, hailed the World Trade Organization's declaration on drug
patents as an important victory for the developing world's fight against
health scourges like AIDS.
The decision also promises to open the way for Brazil to realize a long-held
ambition: to export its low-cost versions of AIDS drugs to countries without
the resources to produce their own.
Such exports have frequently been blocked by confusion surrounding
international patent rules and by pressure from multinational pharmaceutical
companies, which scared off many countries that might have been buyers.
In Brazil's view, the text of the agreement reached at Doha, Qatar, gives
each of the organization's 144 members discretion to set its own rules for
issuing "compulsory licenses," which force patent holders to allow rivals to
manufacture patented drugs. And each country is free under the agreement to
set its own criteria for what constitutes a national public health
emergency, the justification for compulsory licenses.
Before the Doha conference, the question of compulsory licenses had been
left unclear in the organization's 1994 treaty on intellectual property
rights.
Brazil has been on the forefront of attacking AIDS in the developing world
since 1998, when it began copying and producing some of the antiretroviral
drugs used in "cocktails" to treat AIDS. The Health Ministry provides the
cocktails free to patients, and turned to making them domestically when the
cost of importing brand name drugs threatened to bankrupt the program.
Brazilian patent law protects drugs only if they were commercialized after
1997.
Unlike India, where private companies do most of the copycat drug making,
Brazil has made patent breaking a direct activity of the government. Seven
state- owned laboratories now produce generic copies of 8 of the 12 drugs
used in the AIDS cocktail, at a tiny fraction of the prices charged by
multinational pharmaceutical giants like Merck (news/quote) and Roche.
Under pressure from the drug companies, the United States government
threatened to bring a complaint against Brazil at the World Trade
Organization, accusing it of violating the 1994 treaty. The complaint was
dropped after a sustained public outcry, and Brazil reached accommodations
with some of the giant drug makers.
Now, the Brazilian government says, the Doha declaration means that it no
longer has anything to fear from such complaints.
** NOTICE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material
is distributed for research and educational purposes only. **
|
|
|
Last Updated on 11/21/01 Email: information@biotech-info.net |
|